Dervla Broderick

Dervla Broderick

Associate

Gambling

Greece: European Court provides preliminary ruling on the legality of OPAP's monopoly

On 24 January 2013, the Court of Justice of the European Union handed down a preliminary judgment on questions referred to it by the Greek courts in a challenge to OPAP's monopoly brought by UK-based gambling operators, Stanleybet, William Hill and Sportingbet. Given the nature of preliminary references, the Court of Justice was not empowered to declare the monopoly illegal in this instance; the ultimate judgment must be reached by the referring Greek court. However, the Court of Justice strongly intimated that, based on the information before it, OPAP's exclusive rights in relation to the Greek gambling market do not comply with European Union law.

25 January 2013

Competition

Will new OFT guidance succeed in making competition law penalties less open to challenge?

The Office of Fair Trading ("OFT") has issued revised guidance on how it will set financial penalties in future competition law infringement cases. The most significant change is the increase in the maximum starting point for penalty calculations from 10 to 30 per cent of "relevant turnover" (defined as revenue generated in the market affected by the infringing behaviour), bringing the OFT in line with the European Commission and many of its counterparts in other European Member States.

13 September 2012

Television

Sky wins legal challenge against Ofcom's Pay TV decision

On 8 August 2012, the Competition Appeal Tribunal ("CAT") published its much anticipated judgment in the appeals brought by Sky, Virgin Media, BT and the Premier League against Ofcom's 2010 decision to require Sky to offer wholesale access to its premium sports channels at prices set by Ofcom (the "wholesale must offer obligation" or "WMO"). In a significant victory for Sky, the CAT concluded that Ofcom's core competition concern, which underpinned the wholesale access requirement, was not supported by the evidence.

09 August 2012

Gambling

Restrictions on cross-border casino advertising are not prohibited under EU law

On 12 July 2012, the Court of Justice of the European Union delivered a judgment confirming that EU Member States can prohibit cross-border casino advertising on grounds of consumer protection without contravening EU law. However, Member States can only impose such a ban if they have determined that the rules under which the foreign advertiser operates do not ensure equivalent levels of protection against the risks of gaming. In addition, the Member State imposing the ban must ensure that its own rules are proportionate.

13 July 2012

Gambling

The latest news from around Europe

In this update, we report on some of the recent developments in the gambling sector across Europe, including the latest indications from the European Commission that its online gambling action plan will be published by the end of September.

10 July 2012

Pharmaceuticals

Patent Settlement Agreements – How will the US experience impact on the European Commission's decision-making?

With Statements of Objections imminent in several antitrust cases opened by the European Commission following its 2008/2009 pharmaceutical sector inquiry, in this article we examine the experience of the US antitrust regulators in dealing with "pay for delay" settlement agreements. In particular, we look at the recent case of FTC v Watson Pharmaceuticals in which the FTC failed to convince the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit of the per se illegality of such agreements.

14 May 2012

Gambling

The latest news from around Europe

In this update, we report on some of the recent developments in the gambling sector across Europe, including the latest events in Greece, where the government's decision to introduce a retrospective gross gambling revenue tax is being challenged in court.

23 March 2012