Competition Articles

Opinion, Updates & Newsletters

Albion Water awarded damages in the Competition Appeal Tribunal

In a case which has its origins at the introduction of competition in the water sector in England and Wales, Albion Water Limited ("Albion") has finally succeeded in obtaining at least some recompense in its struggle to compete with incumbent Welsh water monopolist, Dŵr Cymru.

24 April 2013

Competition

Brussels Court of Appeal acknowledges in-house legal professional privilege and limits Belgian Competition Authority's power to seize electronic documents during dawn raids.

In a long-awaited and ground breaking judgment on 5 March 2013, the Brussels Court of Appeal acknowledged the existence of legal professional privilege for in-house counsels who are members of the Belgian Institute of In-house Counsel ("IBJ/IJE"). The judgment also imposes significant restrictions on the use of digital search methods by the Belgian Competition Authority ("BCA").

24 April 2013

Competition

UK Government reforms promote competition litigation

The UK Government has announced reforms to the UK competition regime that aim to promote more litigation in competition cases, particularly by small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).  The Government has tried to steer a path between making it easier for businesses to bring cases and avoiding what it sees as the excesses of a"US-style litigation culture".  The reforms are likely to result in more competition risk for businesses engaged in potentially anti-competitive activities - and more opportunities for their victims to seek redress. 

31 January 2013

Competition & Regulatory

The UK criminal cartel offence – a bad reform becomes even more complicated

The UK Government has modified slightly its proposed reform of the criminal cartel offence.  However, the new definition of the offence still raises serious concerns that a wide range of commercial activities will potentially be criminalised.  The Government should back down from this reform altogether. 

11 October 2012

Competition

Belgian Competition Council fines Presstalis for abuse of dominant position

In its decision of 30 July 2012, the Belgian Competition Council imposed a fine of 245,530 Euros on French company Presstalis for abuse of dominant position by applying its so-called "BSC" rebate scheme between 2000 and 2004. The scheme granted rebates to French publishers that allocated their exports to Belgium, Switzerland and Canada exclusively to Presstalis. The Council found that the scheme was loyalty-inducing and restricted competition on the market of exports of French newspapers and magazines on the one hand, and the Belgian distribution market on the other.

19 September 2012

Competition

Will new OFT guidance succeed in making competition law penalties less open to challenge?

The Office of Fair Trading ("OFT") has issued revised guidance on how it will set financial penalties in future competition law infringement cases. The most significant change is the increase in the maximum starting point for penalty calculations from 10 to 30 per cent of "relevant turnover" (defined as revenue generated in the market affected by the infringing behaviour), bringing the OFT in line with the European Commission and many of its counterparts in other European Member States.

13 September 2012

Television

Sky wins legal challenge against Ofcom's Pay TV decision

On 8 August 2012, the Competition Appeal Tribunal ("CAT") published its much anticipated judgment in the appeals brought by Sky, Virgin Media, BT and the Premier League against Ofcom's 2010 decision to require Sky to offer wholesale access to its premium sports channels at prices set by Ofcom (the "wholesale must offer obligation" or "WMO"). In a significant victory for Sky, the CAT concluded that Ofcom's core competition concern, which underpinned the wholesale access requirement, was not supported by the evidence.

09 August 2012

Competition

Competition law challenge to pricing of hotel rooms by online travel agents

The UK competition authorities have formally charged a major hotel group and two online travel agents with breaking competition (antitrust) law by fixing prices at which rooms are sold online.  The case potentially has major implications for all hotel groups and online retailers of accommodation.

02 August 2012

Competition

Towards A New Belgian Competition Act?

There is a large consensus that the current Belgian Competition Act, which dates from 2006, needs some revision, at the very least on a number of procedural issues. This is, in the first instance, the result of the Court of Justice's VEBIC judgement, but there have also been a few decisions from the Competition Council and the Court of Appeal highlighting some shortfalls.

08 June 2012

Competition

Interim Order to Release Minimum Supplies

In an interim order issued on 22 May 2012, the President of the Competition Council ordered a warehouse keeper storing certified Robusta coffee to maintain a minimum amount of loading (at least 500 ton on average) per working day. This is to be measured at the end of each month.

08 June 2012

Financial Services Regulatory

Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive - an update

The Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive ("AIFMD" or the Directive) creates a European-wide framework for regulating managers of ‘Alternative Investment Funds’ ("AIF") (referred to in the Directive as ‘Alternative Investment Fund Managers’ ("AIFM")) and imposes restrictions on “marketing” AIF to investors in the EU.

23 April 2012

Intellectual Property

FAPL and Murphy return to the High Court

Cases C-403/08 and C-429/08: Football Association Premier League Ltd & others vs QC Leisure & Others / Karen Murphy vs Media Protection Services Ltd In October 2011, we reported the European Court of Justice (ECJ) decision in two joined cases. In that decision, the ECJ was answering questions referred to it by the High Court in two UK cases.

20 March 2012